Measuring volatility
Q1. You only have daily open, high, low and close prices. How do you estimate volatility, and which estimator do you pick?
Q1. You only have daily open, high, low and close prices. How do you estimate volatility, and which estimator do you pick?
- Close-to-close: simple, handles drift and overnight gaps, but needs a long window.
- Parkinson and Garman-Klass: use the range, so they are several times more efficient, but assume zero drift and ignore the overnight gap.
- Rogers-Satchell: removes the drift assumption but still ignores the gap.
- Yang-Zhang: combines overnight, open-to-close and Rogers-Satchell terms, so it handles both drift and gaps. It is a good default for stocks with meaningful overnight moves.
Q2. Your 20-day close-to-close volatility is 28%, but Garman-Klass gives 22%. Which is wrong?
Q2. Your 20-day close-to-close volatility is 28%, but Garman-Klass gives 22%. Which is wrong?
Q3. You compute realized variance from 1-second returns and it is far higher than from 5-minute returns. Why?
Q3. You compute realized variance from 1-second returns and it is far higher than from 5-minute returns. Why?
Q4. Should you price options with a GARCH forecast or with implied volatility?
Q4. Should you price options with a GARCH forecast or with implied volatility?
Building the surface
Q5. Walk me through building a volatility surface for HSI options from scratch.
Q5. Walk me through building a volatility surface for HSI options from scratch.
- Clean the data: use out-of-the-money puts and calls, drop zero bids, wide spreads and stale quotes.
- Forward per expiry: use the matching HSI futures price, or back it out from put-call parity near the money.
- Implied volatility per strike with a robust solver.
- Fit each expiry with a smile parameterization such as SVI in total variance against log-moneyness.
- Interpolate across expiries in total variance at fixed moneyness.
- Check arbitrage: total variance must not fall with expiry (calendar), and call prices must be convex in strike (butterfly).
- Extrapolate the wings with a bounded slope.
Q6. How do you get the forward and the implied dividend for a Hong Kong single stock option?
Q6. How do you get the forward and the implied dividend for a Hong Kong single stock option?
- American exercise: Hong Kong stock options are American, so remove the early exercise premium first, for example with a binomial tree, or use only strikes where early exercise is unlikely.
- Separating dividend from borrow: parity gives the combined effect of dividends and borrow cost. Use the dividend forecast and the stock futures price, if one trades, to separate them.
- Ex-dates: a known ex-date before expiry should show up as a jump in the forward, not as a smooth yield.
Q7. Your fitted smile implies a negative probability density in the downside wing. What does that mean and what do you do?
Q7. Your fitted smile implies a negative probability density in the downside wing. What does that mean and what do you do?
Using the surface
Q8. An expiry 10 trading days away contains an earnings date and trades at 50% implied volatility. Normal days are around 30%. What move is the market pricing for earnings?
Q8. An expiry 10 trading days away contains an earnings date and trades at 50% implied volatility. Normal days are around 30%. What move is the market pricing for earnings?
- Total variance: 0.50 squared times 10 divided by 252, or about 0.00992.
- Normal days: 0.30 squared times 9 divided by 252, or about 0.00321.
- Event day: 0.00992 minus 0.00321, or about 0.00671. Its square root is about 8.2%, the one-standard-deviation move.
- Expected absolute move: about 0.8 times that, or 6.5%.
Q9. An index has two stocks with equal weights, each with 30% implied volatility. The index implied volatility is 24%. What correlation is implied, and how would you trade it?
Q9. An index has two stocks with equal weights, each with 30% implied volatility. The index implied volatility is 24%. What correlation is implied, and how would you trade it?
- 0.24 squared is 0.0576.
- The variance terms are 2 times 0.5 squared times 0.09, or 0.045.
- The covariance term is 2 times 0.5 times 0.5 times 0.09 times the correlation, or 0.045 times the correlation.
- So the correlation is (0.0576 minus 0.045) divided by 0.045, or about 0.28.
Q10. What is the skew stickiness ratio, and how does it change your delta?
Q10. What is the skew stickiness ratio, and how does it change your delta?
- Ratio of 1 (sticky strike): no adjustment.
- Ratio above 1 (for example the 1.5 reported for indices), downward skew: a fixed strike’s volatility rises when spot falls. A long call gains some vega in a sell-off, which offsets part of its delta loss, so its effective delta is lower than the Black-Scholes delta and hedging with the Black-Scholes delta over-hedges it.
- Ratio below 1: the adjustment flips sign and the effective delta is higher.
Q11. You issue warrants on a Hong Kong stock whose listed options trade only near the money. How do you set the implied volatility for a far out-of-the-money warrant?
Q11. You issue warrants on a Hong Kong stock whose listed options trade only near the money. How do you set the implied volatility for a far out-of-the-money warrant?
- Start from the fitted surface near the money and extrapolate the skew with a controlled wing slope, cross-checked against similar stocks or the sector’s options.
- Add an issuer margin for short gamma and vega, since you will be short the warrant, and for the hedge being illiquid at that strike.
- Consider existing warrants on the same stock from other issuers, because investors compare implied volatilities across issuers.
- Keep the quoted implied volatility stable after issue, because cutting it lowers the warrant price for investors who already hold it. See Warrants and structured products Q10.
Q12. VHSI jumps from 20 to 30 in a day while the HSI falls 4%. Your book is long downside puts and short at-the-money calls. Explain your P&L.
Q12. VHSI jumps from 20 to 30 in a day while the HSI falls 4%. Your book is long downside puts and short at-the-money calls. Explain your P&L.
- Delta: long puts and short calls are both short delta, so the 4% fall makes money on delta.
- Gamma: long puts are long gamma and short calls are short gamma. Net gamma depends on sizes and where the strikes are after the move.
- Vega: a 10-point rise in a 30-day volatility index is a large vega move. The long puts gain, the short calls lose, and the net depends on vega sizes and how much each strike’s volatility rose. Downside strikes usually rise more in a sell-off, which helps this book.
- Skew: a steeper skew helps a book that is long downside and short upside, which is a long risk-reversal-against-the-market position.
Related pages
- Volatility estimation and the implied volatility surface
- Options, Greeks and volatility mock interview
- Mock Interview overview
Sources
- Range-based volatility estimators: overview and examples of usage, Portfolio Optimizer
- Yang-Zhang versus close-to-close volatility, FlashAlpha
- Arbitrage-free SVI volatility surfaces, Gatheral and Jacquier
- Computing the SSR, Friz and Gatheral
- On the skew stickiness ratio, Fukasawa
- HSI Volatility Index futures, HKEX
- Derivatives pricing interview questions, Quantt
- Options pricing interview questions, QuantVault

