Skip to main content
This page covers ETF market making and arbitrage questions for Delta-1 and ETF desks. Each question has a main question, common follow-ups and answer points. The answers are thinking frameworks, so say out loud how you would check each assumption. For market rule details, use the matching pages on this site rather than repeating them in an interview.
Status of this page. Last checked on 15 November 2026. These are general practice frameworks, not any firm’s interview content or desk practice. Specific rules, numbers and terms are governed by each market’s pages and the current exchange and ETF documents.

Mechanism and roles

They do different jobs, and one firm can do both. The market maker quotes bids and offers in the secondary market (the exchange), usually under obligations for minimum size and maximum spread. The authorized participant (AP) deals with the ETF issuer in the primary market, where it creates and redeems ETF shares.
  • Market making trades existing shares. AP activity changes the total share count.
  • A market maker that is not an AP can still ask an AP to create or redeem on its behalf when it needs large size.
  • When the firm quotes a client, it is acting as a market maker. When it delivers a basket and receives new shares, it is acting as an AP.
Follow-up: Why does the mechanism keep the ETF close to NAV?→ If the ETF trades above the value of its basket, an AP can buy the basket, deliver it to create shares and sell the shares at the higher price. If it trades below, the AP buys the shares, redeems them for the basket and sells the basket. Both trades push the price back toward NAV. See ETF creation and redemption.
You do not need the exchange order book to hold that size. Because shares can be created, the supply is elastic.Steps:
  • Quote the client based on the fair value of the underlying basket plus a charge for hedging cost, size and risk.
  • Hedge the market exposure as soon as the client trades, using futures, the basket or a correlated ETF.
  • Create new ETF shares through an AP to cover the short position, then unwind the temporary hedge.
Risks to name: the market moves between the client trade and the creation, the basket may not be fully tradable at the quoted prices, and the creation has cut-off and settlement timing. See ETF creation, redemption and arbitrage (Hong Kong).

Pricing and quoting

Start from a fair value and then add the market maker’s adjustments.
  • Fair value: the live value of the basket, using the most reliable inputs available (constituent prices, index futures, FX, related ETFs and ADRs when the underlying market is closed).
  • Spread: wide enough to cover hedging cost, adverse selection and the risk of a stale fair value, but within the exchange obligations.
  • Inventory skew: if you are long, move both quotes down to encourage selling, and the reverse if you are short.
  • Hedge cost: the cost and liquidity of the instrument you will hedge with.
Follow-up: What makes you widen or pull quotes?→ Stale or missing underlying prices, a volatility spike, a halted constituent, a data feed problem or a hedge instrument that is no longer liquid. See the market maker rules for the obligations that apply in Hong Kong.
Not necessarily. First ask whether the NAV is stale. The NAV after the US close is the previous closing value, while the ETF during Hong Kong hours reflects the market’s expectation of where US stocks will open.Steps to check:
  • Recompute a live fair value using US index futures that are still trading, ADRs or FX, and compare it with the ETF price.
  • If the deviation disappears after recomputing, it was an information lag, not a mispricing.
  • If a deviation remains, then consider arbitrage costs and execution feasibility.
Follow-up: If you go ahead, how do you lock it in?→ You can use related futures that are still trading to hedge the directional exposure first, then deal with the basket and creation or redemption once the constituent market opens. Residual risks are basis, FX, the opening gap and creation and redemption cut-off times.

Arbitrage risks

  • Execution risk (legging): Buying the whole constituent basket and selling the ETF do not happen at the same moment, and prices move in between.
  • Settlement and timing: Creation and redemption have cut-off times and settlement cycles, and the position is exposed to the market during that gap.
  • Basket versus actual composition: The actual creation list can differ from the index constituents or the cash component.
  • Borrow and financing: A redemption arbitrage needs the basket shorted, and borrow availability and cost can change.
  • Size and liquidity: With illiquid constituents, real fills differ from theoretical values.
Follow-up: Which of these risks can be hedged with futures?→ Directional market risk can, but execution, borrow and basket-difference risks cannot. See Delta-1: hedging with listed derivatives.
The mechanism pulls the price toward NAV, but it only works when someone has the capacity and the incentive to do the trade.
  • Costs: The gap must be larger than fees, spreads, financing and the capital used.
  • Constraints: Balance sheet limits, borrow availability, position limits and any restriction on creation or redemption in the ETF or the constituent market.
  • Closed or restricted constituent markets: If the basket cannot be traded, the price gap reflects uncertainty about the true value, not an easy arbitrage.
  • Stress: When underlying liquidity drops, APs and market makers may step back, and discounts can widen exactly when the NAV itself is uncertain.
Follow-up: How do you tell a real discount from a stale NAV?→ Compare the ETF with a live estimate built from tradable proxies. If the gap vanishes, it was stale pricing. If it remains and the proxies are reliable, it is a candidate trade, subject to the costs above.
A wider basis (futures minus spot) means the futures become richer relative to spot. You are long the ETF and short the futures, so you have an unrealized loss on the position.But the basis converges to zero at expiry, so if you hold to expiry the loss reverses (ignoring margin financing and roll cost). If you close out or roll while the basis is wide, you realize the loss.Follow-up: Should you stop out?→ First work out why the basis widened: financing cost, dividend expectations, a temporary imbalance caused by program buying, or a structural change. Then look at margin and funding capacity and position limits. The basis tends to converge, but you must be able to carry the position until it does.
When constituents go ex-dividend, a price-return index falls by roughly the weighted dividend amount, and the ETF’s NAV reflects that change. A total-return index does not drop, because it reinvests the dividend, so check which version the futures and the ETF track. The futures price already includes the expected dividend, so futures and spot do not move in sync around the ex-date.The key point is that the difference between expected and actual dividends becomes basis risk. When ETF holders receive dividends and whether they are reinvested depends on the ETF’s own documents, so say in the interview that you would check the product documentation.

Quick pricing and product variations

The ETF’s fair value moves by the weight times the stock’s return: 7% times 2% is 0.14%, so the new fair value is about 50 times 1.0014, or 50.07.Candidate reports from ETF market makers describe this kind of quick repricing question in the technical round, often with awkward numbers so that you have to estimate under time pressure.Follow-up: In practice the other stocks rarely stay unchanged. How would you update fair value if only one stock has printed?→ Use the stocks that have traded plus a proxy (index futures or a correlated ETF) for the rest, and weight your confidence in each input. A single print in a large constituent moves the fair value, but the rest of the basket usually moves with it through correlation.
A daily leveraged fund must reset its exposure at each close to the target multiple of its new NAV. The rebalance trade is approximately the leverage factor times (leverage factor minus 1) times the day’s return times NAV.
  • 2x long: 2 times 1 is 2. A 3% up day on a fund with 1 billion NAV needs about 60 million of extra exposure.
  • Inverse (minus 1x): minus 1 times minus 2 is also 2, so the same 3% up day needs about 60 million of buying to cover part of the short.
  • Minus 2x: minus 2 times minus 3 is 6, so it needs about 180 million.
Because the factor is positive for both leveraged and inverse funds, the rebalance always trades in the direction of the day’s move, usually near the close. That is short-gamma behavior: it adds to momentum into the close.Why it matters: the flow is predictable, so the desk anticipates it in the closing auction and in its hedges. It also explains why leveraged funds drift from the multiple of the index over periods longer than a day (volatility decay), which comes up as a follow-up.Follow-up: Why can’t the fund just hold a fixed amount of futures?→ Then its exposure would no longer be the target multiple of NAV after the first move. The daily objective forces the reset.
The mechanism is the same, but the constraints are tighter. Points to name, and to say you would check against the current rules and the fund’s documents:
  • Access and creation: the manager usually reaches A-shares through Stock Connect or a qualified foreign investor channel, and creations and redemptions are commonly in cash rather than in kind. You do not deliver the basket yourself, so you carry execution risk on the manager’s trades through the creation fee and the dealing terms.
  • Hedging: single A-shares are hard to short for offshore investors, so hedges are usually index futures traded offshore (for example A50 futures) or a correlated ETF, with basis risk to the actual basket.
  • Market rules: daily price limits on A-shares, a rule that shares bought cannot be sold on the same day, and Stock Connect trading days that differ from both markets’ calendars around holidays. When the underlying is limit up or limit down, the NAV is not a tradable price.
  • Currency: the basket is in onshore renminbi (CNY), while hedges and quotes may be in offshore renminbi (CNH) or Hong Kong dollars, so there is a CNY versus CNH basis.
Follow-up: The A-share market hits limit down and the ETF keeps trading in Hong Kong at a deep discount to NAV. Is the discount real?→ Largely yes. The NAV uses prices you cannot trade at, so the ETF is acting as the price discovery venue. Quote from your best estimate of where the basket would clear, with a wide spread.

Sources