Fair value and arbitrage
Q2. Explain the creation and redemption arbitrage. When do you create and when do you redeem?
Q2. Explain the creation and redemption arbitrage. When do you create and when do you redeem?
- ETF at a premium (price above NAV): Buy the constituent basket, deliver it to the issuer for ETF units (creation), and sell the ETF in the market.
- ETF at a discount (price below NAV): Buy the ETF, redeem it with the issuer for the constituents, and sell the constituents in the market.
Q4. What is the difference between tracking error and tracking difference?
Q4. What is the difference between tracking error and tracking difference?
- Tracking difference: The cumulative gap between ETF return and index return over a period. It mainly reflects fees, dividend handling and cash drag.
- Tracking error: The volatility of that gap, usually the annualized standard deviation of daily or weekly return differences.
Market making
Q5. How do you set a bid-ask spread for an ETF? What are the components?
Q5. How do you set a bid-ask spread for an ETF? What are the components?
- Hedging cost: Trading cost and basis risk when hedging with futures or constituents.
- Inventory risk: Price movement while holding an unhedged position.
- Adverse selection: Counterparties may know more than you (for example a stale NAV, or futures that have already moved).
- Fixed costs and taxes: Fees, stamp duty and similar. See Trading rules.
- Profit target and quoting obligations: See Market maker rules.
Q6. How should a market maker adjust quotes when inventory builds up?
Q6. How should a market maker adjust quotes when inventory builds up?
r = s − q γ σ² (T − t), where q is inventory, γ is risk aversion and σ is volatility. The larger the inventory, the higher the volatility and the longer the remaining time, the larger the shift.This is a conceptual framework. In practice, if inventory can be hedged immediately with futures, its effective risk is lower than unhedged inventory, so the shift can be smaller.Q7. What is adverse selection in market making and how do you detect it?
Q7. What is adverse selection in market making and how do you detect it?
- Analyze price movement shortly after fills (seconds to minutes), the post-trade markout. A systematic move against you indicates adverse selection.
- Check whether fills happen after a futures or related instrument has already moved, which means your quote was stale.
- Compare markouts by client type, time of day and order size.
Q8. How do you hedge ETF inventory with index futures, and what risks remain?
Q8. How do you hedge ETF inventory with index futures, and what risks remain?
- Basis risk: The futures-spot spread moves and only converges at expiry.
- Tracking and composition differences: The index the ETF tracks may not exactly match the futures underlying.
- Dividends and timing: Dividends affect the futures and the ETF NAV differently.
- Whole contracts: Contract counts are integers, so a residual remains.
- Roll cost: Futures must be rolled before expiry.
Leveraged and inverse ETFs
Q9. Why does a 2x daily leveraged ETF not return twice the index over a long period?
Q9. Why does a 2x daily leveraged ETF not return twice the index over a long period?
L μ − (1/2) L² σ², while the index’s is μ − (1/2) σ². Compared with L times the index’s log return, the gap is −(1/2) L (L − 1) σ². For L = 2 the gap is about −σ². This is volatility decay.Implications: leveraged ETFs lose value in choppy, trendless, high-volatility markets, and in strongly one-directional trends they can exceed L times the index. An inverse ETF (L = −1) has drag −(1/2)(−1)(−2) σ² = −σ², so it also suffers.Q10. A leveraged ETF must rebalance daily. How large is the rebalancing flow and in which direction?
Q10. A leveraged ETF must rebalance daily. How large is the rebalancing flow and in which direction?
L (L − 1) × AUM × (index return that day).- Index up, L above 1: the fund must buy more of the underlying (chasing the rally).
- Index down, L above 1: the fund must sell (selling into the decline).
- Inverse ETF (L = −1):
L (L − 1) = 2, so the flow is also in the same direction as the index. When the index rises, fund NAV falls and the fund must cover shorts (buy the underlying). When the index falls, it must add to shorts (sell the underlying).
Delta-1 swaps
Q11. What goes into the price of a Delta-1 total return swap on a stock?
Q11. What goes into the price of a Delta-1 total return swap on a stock?
- Benchmark rate and funding spread (reflecting cost of funds and capital usage)
- Borrow cost, especially when the client is short
- Dividend handling and tax (withholding tax and dividend tax rates differ by market and investor)
- Hedging cost and liquidity

