Status of this page: P0 draft. Worked numbers were checked by calculation; model results (Leland, Whalley-Wilmott) are asymptotic and should be tested on the desk’s own data.
1. P&L of a delta-hedged option
Over a short interval, the delta-hedged P&L is approximatelyP&L = 0.5 x Gamma_$ x (r^2 - sigma_imp^2 x dt) + vega x d(sigma_imp) + theta residual
where Gamma_$ = Gamma x S^2 is dollar gamma, r is the realised return in the interval, and dt is the interval in years. The first term is the realised-versus-implied variance bet.
Worked example (verified). Gamma_$ = 5,000,000, implied vol 25%, daily interval.
- Breakeven daily move = 25% / sqrt(252) = 1.575%.
- A 2% move: 0.5 x 5,000,000 x (0.02^2 - 0.01575^2) = about +380.
- A 1% move: about -370.
2. Discrete hedging error
If the true process is Black-Scholes and the hedge is rebalanced N times to expiry, the hedging error has standard deviation of order 1/sqrt(N) times a term proportional to vega-like exposure (Boyle and Emanuel, 1980). Practical drivers beyond N:- Gamma near the strike close to expiry.
- Jumps and gaps, which a continuous model cannot hedge.
- Misspecified vol: the hedge delta uses sigma_hedge, and the P&L depends on realised minus hedge-vol, not implied.
3. Hedging with transaction costs
Leland (1985) proposes pricing with an adjusted vol: sigma_adj^2 = sigma^2 x (1 + Le), where Le = sqrt(2/pi) x k / (sigma x sqrt(dt)) and k is the proportional cost per trade. Verified examples with k = 0.1% and sigma = 25%: daily rebalancing gives Le = 0.051 and sigma_adj of about 25.6%; hourly rebalancing (8 per day) gives Le = 0.143 and sigma_adj of about 26.7%. Caveat: Zhao and Ziemba (2003) argue that Leland’s main convergence theorem is flawed, and that exact replication is not achieved in the limit. Treat the formula as a heuristic for cost-adjusted vol, not a replication proof. No-trade band (Whalley and Wilmott). The optimal policy under proportional costs is to hedge only when delta leaves a band around the Black-Scholes delta. The half-width scales with lambda^(1/3), where lambda is the proportional cost, and also depends on gamma and risk aversion. Doubling the cost widens the band by about 26%, not 100%.4. Desk-level implications
- Hedge on delta bands tied to gamma and spread, not only to a clock.
- Aggregate across the book: netting reduces cost more than per-option bands do.
- Hedge instrument choice (futures vs cash vs ETF) changes both cost and basis risk. See Delta-1 hedging.
- Separate the P&L explain into gamma-theta, vega, hedge slippage, and carry.
Points to verify
- Exact band formula and constants in Whalley and Wilmott (1997) before implementing.
- HK stamp duty and fee exemptions for market-maker hedges, which materially change k.
Sources
- Leland (1985), Option pricing and replication with transactions costs, Journal of Finance.
- Zhao and Ziemba (2003), On Leland’s Option Hedging Strategy with Transaction Costs.
- Toft (1996), On the Mean-Variance Tradeoff in Option Replication with Transactions Costs, JFQA 31(2).
- Whalley and Wilmott (1997), An asymptotic analysis of an optimal hedging model for option pricing with transaction costs, Mathematical Finance.
- Boyle and Emanuel (1980), Discretely adjusted option hedges, Journal of Financial Economics.

