Pricing relationships
Q1. State put-call parity. What do you do if it is violated?
Q1. State put-call parity. What do you do if it is violated?
C − P = S − K e^(−rT).- Continuous dividend yield q:
C − P = S e^(−qT) − K e^(−rT) - Discrete dividends: replace S with
S − PV(dividends)
C − P is above the right-hand side, sell the call, buy the put, buy the stock and borrow cash. In practice, borrow cost, funding rates and bid-ask spreads mean parity holds as a band rather than an equality. Conversely, you can back out the implied borrow cost or implied dividend from call and put prices.Q2. What is the fair forward or futures price of a stock or index? When does cash-and-carry arbitrage work?
Q2. What is the fair forward or futures price of a stock or index? When does cash-and-carry arbitrage work?
F = S e^((r − q) T). With discrete dividends: F = (S − PV(D)) e^(rT).If F is above this value: buy the spot, sell the future and deliver at expiry (cash-and-carry). If F is below: short the spot and buy the future (reverse cash-and-carry). The basis, F minus S, comes from financing cost net of expected dividends and converges to zero at expiry.In practice, borrow cost, funding spreads, dividend uncertainty and margin all widen the no-arbitrage band. This is also the basis for Delta-1 arbitrage between index futures and ETFs. See Delta-1: hedging with listed derivatives.Q3. Explain risk-neutral pricing. Why does the real-world drift not appear in the Black-Scholes price?
Q3. Explain risk-neutral pricing. Why does the real-world drift not appear in the Black-Scholes price?
V = e^(−rT) E_Q[payoff]. This does not mean market participants are risk neutral. It is a computational device. Volatility σ stays in the formula because the replication cost depends on how much the path moves.Q4. Should you ever exercise an American call early? An American put?
Q4. Should you ever exercise an American call early? An American put?
Q5. How do dividends affect call and put prices?
Q5. How do dividends affect call and put prices?
S e^(−qT) in put-call parity.For trading: dividend expectations and dividend risk are separate risk factors, and they remain after delta hedging. See the Dividends row in Delta-1: hedging with listed derivatives.Black-Scholes and its limits
Q6. List the Black-Scholes assumptions. Which fail most badly in practice?
Q6. List the Black-Scholes assumptions. Which fail most badly in practice?
- Constant volatility: Real markets show a volatility smile or skew, and volatility itself moves randomly over time.
- Continuous paths: Real prices jump (earnings, events, gaps at the open), and delta hedging cannot fully remove jump risk.
- No transaction costs and continuous hedging: Discrete hedging and costs leave residual P&L noise.
Q8. You are long a delta-hedged option. What is your daily P&L, and when do you make money?
Q8. You are long a delta-hedged option. What is your daily P&L, and when do you make money?
P&L ≈ (1/2) Γ S² [ (ΔS / S)² − σ_implied² × dt ].You make money when the realized squared return exceeds the implied variance for that day, that is, when realized volatility is higher than implied volatility. Long gamma loses in the opposite case. This is the core of volatility trading: trading an option is essentially trading the gap between realized and implied volatility.This is an approximation. Vega P&L (the move in implied volatility itself) is separate, and how gamma is distributed across strikes and maturities affects the actual result.Q9. Where is gamma largest? Where is vega largest? How do they change near expiry?
Q9. Where is gamma largest? Where is vega largest? How do they change near expiry?
- Gamma: Largest at the money (ATM). Near expiry, ATM gamma rises sharply (pin risk) while in-the-money and out-of-the-money gamma goes to zero.
- Vega: Largest near the money and increasing with time to expiry (vega is roughly proportional to √T). Vega goes to zero near expiry.
- Theta: ATM options decay fastest close to expiry.
Volatility surface
Q10. Why do equity index options show negative skew?
Q10. Why do equity index options show negative skew?
- Hedging demand: Institutions buy puts to protect holdings, which pushes put prices up.
- Leverage effect: When the stock falls, leverage rises and so does volatility, giving a negative correlation between price and volatility.
- Crash risk premium: Investors pay a premium for downside tail protection.
Q11. What is the difference between sticky strike and sticky delta? Why does it matter for hedging?
Q11. What is the difference between sticky strike and sticky delta? Why does it matter for hedging?
- Sticky strike: When the underlying moves, the implied volatility at each fixed strike stays unchanged.
- Sticky delta (sticky moneyness): Implied volatility moves with moneyness, so when the underlying rises, the implied volatility at a given strike changes with it.
vega × (∂σ / ∂S). Your choice of assumption affects hedge ratios and P&L attribution.Q12. How would you check a vol surface for arbitrage?
Q12. How would you check a vol surface for arbitrage?
- Calendar spread: At a fixed strike, total variance
σ² × Tmust increase with maturity, otherwise a calendar spread is an arbitrage. - Butterfly: At a fixed maturity, option price must be a convex function of strike, which means the implied risk-neutral density cannot be negative.

