Skip to main content
Status of this page: P0 draft. Model-level; empirical magnitudes are quoted only where cited.

1. Why queue position matters

Under price-time priority, an order at the back of a long queue at the touch fills only after the orders ahead are executed or cancelled. Moallemi and Yuan model the value of a limit order as a function of its queue position, incorporating adverse selection and queueing dynamics, and find that queue value can be of the same order of magnitude as the bid-ask spread. Huang et al. (2019) reach a similar conclusion in an agent-based order book model. Consequence: in large-tick products, queue priority is an asset that has to be priced.

2. Components of a fill model

For a passive order at the touch, the fill depends on:
  1. Orders ahead (position in queue at submission).
  2. Cancellations ahead (reduce the queue without trading).
  3. Market orders arriving at that side before the price moves away.
  4. Price move (if the touch moves away, the order is no longer at the touch).
Simple benchmark: if volume at the touch trades at rate mu (shares per unit time) and cancellations ahead are ignored, expected time to fill is roughly (shares ahead) / mu. Including cancellations shortens the wait; including price moves lowers the probability of ever filling.

3. Adverse selection of a passive fill

Fills are not random: a bid fills more often when the price is about to fall. The conditional expected mid move after a fill is therefore negative for a buy order. Any estimate of passive-order profit must use the post-fill mid move, not the unconditional one. This is why a realised-spread calculation is a better backtest metric than quoted spread (order book and spread).

4. Modelling approaches

5. Estimating queue position

  • With a full order-by-order feed, reconstruct position exactly from order IDs.
  • With only level-aggregated data, position is uncertain: assume a conservative rule (placed at the back) and an optimistic rule (pro-rata) and report both. A strategy that only works under the optimistic rule is not validated.

6. Backtesting implication

A naive backtest that fills a passive order when the price touches the limit price overstates fills and understates adverse selection. Use a fill model with an explicit queue assumption and a latency assumption. Detail on tick simulation and fills.

Points to verify

  • Whether the HKEX data feed in use carries order-level (broker queue) information or only aggregated depth.
  • Priority rules for special order types (at-auction, enhanced limit) at HKEX.

Sources

  • Moallemi and Yuan (2016), A Model for Queue Position Valuation in a Limit Order Book. PDF
  • Huang, Pulido, Rosenbaum, Saliba and Sfendourakis (2019), From Glosten-Milgrom to the whole limit order book and applications to financial regulation. arXiv
  • Maglaras, Moallemi and Zheng (2015), Optimal execution in a limit order book and an associated microstructure market impact model. PDF