Skip to main content
Status of this page: P0 draft. Formulas follow Avellaneda and Stoikov (2008) as commonly stated; verify against the paper before implementing. Numerical example checked by calculation. Product-level obligations are on HK market maker rules and mock ETF market making.

1. The Avellaneda-Stoikov (A-S) model

Setup: mid price follows arithmetic Brownian motion with volatility sigma; the market maker has CARA utility with risk aversion gamma, holds inventory q, and trades until T. Fill intensity at distance delta from the mid is lambda(delta) = A x exp(-k x delta). Two outputs:
  • Reservation price r = s - q x gamma x sigma^2 x (T - t). Positive inventory lowers r, so the maker quotes lower to sell and discourages further buying.
  • Optimal total spread = gamma x sigma^2 x (T - t) + (2 / gamma) x ln(1 + gamma / k). Quotes are placed symmetrically around r.
Worked example (verified). s = 100, gamma = 0.1, sigma = 2, T - t = 1, k = 1.5.
  • Spread = 0.4 + 1.291 = 1.691.
  • Inventory 0: reservation 100.0, bid 99.15, ask 100.85.
  • Inventory +5: reservation 98.0, bid 97.15, ask 98.85. The whole quote shifts down by 2.0, i.e. by q x gamma x sigma^2 x tau.

2. What the model leaves out

  • Adverse selection: the mid is exogenous and no trade is informative. In practice this is the dominant cost; add a flow-toxicity term or widen the spread where order-flow imbalance is high.
  • Fill intensity form: the exponential form is an assumption. Estimate lambda(delta) from own fills, including queue position effects (queue position and fills).
  • Discreteness: continuous quotes ignore the tick size. Quotes must be rounded to the tick grid, which can dominate the optimal spread in large-tick stocks.
  • Constant sigma: use a short-horizon vol estimate and a floor.
  • Terminal horizon: the finite T produces a spread that shrinks toward the end; many implementations use an infinite-horizon variant or a rolling horizon.

3. Practical extensions

  1. Inventory limits and skew caps: hard position bounds, with quote withdrawal on the side that would breach.
  2. Signal skew: shift the reservation price by a short-horizon alpha (imbalance, hedge-instrument move).
  3. Hedging inventory: for ETFs or options the inventory can be hedged with futures or baskets, so the relevant risk is the residual after hedge, not q itself.
  4. Obligation-aware quoting: exchange requirements on spread, size, and uptime constrain the optimum; model them as constraints.
  5. Multi-asset: inventory risk becomes a covariance term; skews depend on the whole portfolio.

4. Evaluating a quoting model

  • Compare realised spread, fill rate, inventory distribution, and P&L variance against a baseline of fixed-width quotes.
  • Run in a simulator that models queue position and adverse selection, otherwise A-S looks better than it is (tick simulation and fills).

Points to verify

  • Exact form of the optimal spread when the horizon term is dropped (infinite-horizon variants).
  • Calibration of k and A on HKEX data for the products of interest.

Sources

  • Avellaneda and Stoikov (2008), High-frequency trading in a limit order book, Quantitative Finance 8(3).
  • Biais, Glosten and Spatt (2005), for the economic components that A-S omits.